Online Now 192

Cemetery Hill

The place for Tiger fans to talk football, basketball and recruiting

On this Board 78
Record: 2484 (7/31/2012)

Online now 251
Record: 3605 (4/12/2012)

Reply

A look at the stars

  • http://clemson.247sports.com/Article/A-look-at-the-stars-Clemson-football-recruiting-rankings-115750

    How do our rankings of Clemson commits compare to those of the other major sites? We compare the final rankings.

    Keith Niebuhr

  • I have come to the conclusion that Scout is just clueless. They probably should find another line of work.

    jvtiger77

  • jvtiger77 said...

    I have come to the conclusion that Scout is just clueless. They probably should find another line of work.

    Hahaha ...

    Opinions vary about all of us, I suppose.

    Keith Niebuhr

  • This is another great write up and question.
    Seems like ESPN is the most generous to our Clemson commits, but that's cool.
    Things that stick out the most to me are:
    Shaq Lawson/ Scout 3* ranking
    Pagano/ 24/7 3*
    Leggett/ #57 TE
    TJ Green/ ESPN 4* and Rivals 2* (by his film I'd lean more toward ESPN)
    Dye/ Scout, there is NO WAY there are 27 better RB's than Dye

    ChasTiger80

  • jvtiger77 said...

    I have come to the conclusion that Scout is just clueless. They probably should find another line of work.

    Scout used to be much better, but they have really fallen off...it might be due to the emergence of 247...who knows.

    ESPN's seems more generous because they have way more 4 stars than the others. I've always liked Rivals the best as a rankings service, but 247 has gotten much better and I think they got some right this year that rivals got wrong, but I'm sure it goes both ways.

    acwill07

Clemson
247Sports
Features
Resources
Connect

247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports